Current:Home > StocksCourt says judge had no authority to halt Medicare Advantage plan for Delaware government retirees -GrowthInsight
Court says judge had no authority to halt Medicare Advantage plan for Delaware government retirees
View
Date:2025-04-17 03:30:06
DOVER, Del. (AP) — Delaware’s Supreme Court has overturned a lower court ruling that prevented officials from moving state government retirees from a Medicare supplement plan to a Medicare Advantage plan.
The justices ruled Friday that a Superior Court judge had no jurisdiction to enter the stay because he wrongly determined that the state panel that approved the Medicare Advantage plan had violated the state’s Administrative Procedures Act. The selection of a particular Medicare plan is not a regulation subject to APA notice and public hearing requirements, and the judge therefore had no jurisdiction under the APA to halt the plan, the court said.
Justice Abigail LeGrow, writing for a three-judge panel, said a regulation under the APA is a statement of law, procedure or policy that is used as a rule or standard to guide, regulate, or act as a model for future action. The choice of a Medicare plan does not fall within the plain meaning of those terms, she said.
“Accordingly, the Superior Court did not have jurisdiction to enter the challenged stay, and we reverse the decision on appeal,” LeGrow wrote. “The important policy considerations that attend the selection of healthcare coverage for state retirees are questions appropriately addressed to the legislative and executive branches.”
The court rejected an appeal by plan opponents seeking to force the state to pay their attorney fees because of the state’s “reprehensible conduct.” Fee shifting, available only against a losing party, was mooted by the reversal of the lower court decision, LeGrow noted.
In February 2022, the State Employee Benefits Committee unanimously agreed to replace a Medicare part A and B supplemental plan with a new Part C Medicare Advantage plan, effective Jan. 1, 2023. The move set off a firestorm of opposition from state retirees and, in turn, prompted lawmakers to introduce legislation eliminating the option of providing state pensioners with a Medicare Advantage plan.
Opponents, including former Democratic state Sen. Karen Peterson, were particularly unhappy with the prospect of having fewer medical providers to choose from and needing prior authorization for many medical procedures.
In October 2022, Superior Court Judge Calvin Scott Jr. halted implementation of the Medicare Advantage plan, saying it amounted to a new regulation under the APA. He rejected the administration’s argument that the State Employee Benefits Committee was authorized by law to change retiree healthcare plans without following formal APA requirements.
In the wake of the lawsuit, the State Employee Benefits Committee and Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield agreed last year to terminate the Medicare Advantage contract. The State Employee Benefits Committee also voted to solicit bids for a new Medicare supplement plan.
Meanwhile, lawmakers introduced a bill to add a state retiree and an additional representative of organized labor to the State Employee Benefits Committee, and to establish a Retiree Healthcare Benefits Advisory Subcommittee. Democratic Gov. John Carney signed the bill into law last year just two weeks after it was introduced.
A separate bill eliminating the option of providing state pensioners with a Medicare Advantage plan was introduced this year. It was amended last month to allow a Medicare Advantage plan as an option for eligible pensioners hired on or after Jan. 1, 2025, but only if the plan is adopted by the State Employee Benefits Committee as a regulation under the APA. The bill passed the House unanimously last month and is awaiting consideration by a Senate committee.
veryGood! (2)
Related
- Dick Vitale announces he is cancer free: 'Santa Claus came early'
- Why 'Tyler from Spartanburg' torching Dabo Swinney may have saved Clemson football season
- Record-breaking Storm Ciarán kills at least 5 in Italy, trapping residents and overturning cars: A wave of water bombs
- Michael J. Fox calls breaking bones due to Parkinson's symptoms a 'tsunami of misfortune'
- Where will Elmo go? HBO moves away from 'Sesame Street'
- Winners and losers of college football's Week 10: Georgia, Oklahoma State have big days
- Meg Ryan explains that 'What Happens Later' movie ending: 'I hope it's not a cop out'
- Reneé Rapp duets with Kesha, shows off powerhouse voice at stunning New York concert
- Romantasy reigns on spicy BookTok: Recommendations from the internet’s favorite genre
- FDA proposes banning ingredient found in some citrus-flavored sodas
Ranking
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Hi Hi!
- World Series MVP Corey Seager takes shot at Astros during Rangers' championship parade
- Celebrities running in the 2023 NYC Marathon on Sunday
- Matthew Perry Foundation launched to help people with drug addiction
- Sarah J. Maas books explained: How to read 'ACOTAR,' 'Throne of Glass' in order.
- Anthropologie Is Offering an Extra 40% Off Their Sale Section Right Now and We Can’t Get Enough Of It
- U.S. regulators will review car-tire chemical that kills salmon, upon request from West Coast tribes
- Michael J. Fox calls breaking bones due to Parkinson's symptoms a 'tsunami of misfortune'
Recommendation
'Squid Game' without subtitles? Duolingo, Netflix encourage fans to learn Korean
Off-duty Los Angeles police officer, passenger killed by suspected drunken driver, authorities say
Estonia will allow Taiwan to establish a nondiplomatic representative office in a policy revision
How a Texas teacher helped students use their imaginations to take flight
$73.5M beach replenishment project starts in January at Jersey Shore
The hostage situation at Hamburg Airport ends with a man in custody and 4-year-old daughter safe
Her son ended his life with a gun. Driven to her knees, she found hope.
Defeat of Florida increases buyout of Arkansas coach Sam Pittman by more than $5 million