Current:Home > ContactGeorgia judge needs more time in lawsuit over blocking the state’s ban on gender-affirming care -GrowthInsight
Georgia judge needs more time in lawsuit over blocking the state’s ban on gender-affirming care
Johnathan Walker View
Date:2025-04-09 22:31:35
ATLANTA (AP) — A federal judge deciding whether to block a Georgia law that bans hormone replacement therapies for transgender people under 18 said Friday there were “significant interests” on both sides and she would need more time to rule.
At the end of nearly two full days of hearings in Atlanta, Judge Sarah Geraghty said she heard conflicting testimony from witnesses about the safety and benefits of hormone therapy to treat adolescents with gender dysphoria — the distress felt when someone’s gender expression does not match their gender identity.
“I need to process the evidence we’ve heard in the past two days and take some additional time to make sure I get this right,” she said.
She did not indicate when she would rule.
The law, which was passed this year by the Republican majority in the General Assembly, took effect in July. It allows doctors to prescribe puberty-blocking medications, and it allows minors who are already receiving hormone therapy to continue treatment.
But the law bans any new patients under 18 from starting hormone therapy. It also bans most gender-affirming surgeries for transgender people under 18.
Doctors typically guide kids toward therapy or voice coaching long before medical intervention.
At that point, puberty blockers and other hormone treatments are far more common than surgery. They have been available in the United States for more than a decade and are standard treatments backed by major doctors’ organizations including the American Medical Association.
The parents of four transgender girls have filed a lawsuit challenging its constitutionality and have also asked Judge Geraghty to block its enforcement while the litigation is pending. The lawsuit names state health officials as defendants.
Georgia is one of at least 20 states that have recently adopted laws restricting or banning gender-affirming care for transgender minors, with most of them are being challenged in court.
On Friday, Geraghty heard more testimony as well as closing arguments from attorneys.
Ren Massey, a psychologist in Georgia who treats transgender adolescents, said children struggling with their gender identity undergo a comprehensive assessment before discussing treatment plans. That assessment looks at the possibility of other mental health issues and the length of time they’ve expressed questions about their gender identity, among other factors.
A team consisting of the patients, their parents and health care providers typically discuss the benefits and risks of a treatment, and monitor their progress closely. Hormone therapy, if it is prescribed, comes years later, he said.
Massey called Georgia’s law “unethical,” because “it’s withholding treatment that we know is beneficial,” he testified.
During cross-examination, an attorney for the state said that passages of a report that Massey submitted to the court were identical or nearly identical to those in a report written by another expert. Massey did not dispute the similarities between the reports, which both expressed opposition to the Georgia law.
Though he said he has never treated an adolescent with gender dysphoria, Michael Laidlaw, an endocrinologist in California, testified for the defense about hormone doses given to some adolescents as “exceedingly high.”
“Hormones are very powerful medications,” Laidlaw said.
On cross-examination, he was also confronted with a legal brief he co-authored for the U.S. Supreme Court that called gender dysphoria among youth a “false belief” and accused young people diagnosed with it of engaging in a “charade.”
The judge then asked Ben Bradshaw, an attorney for the plaintiffs, how she should weigh the risks of hormone treatments in her decision.
Bradshaw said the treatment is safe and appropriate when prescribed properly, and its benefits far outweigh any risks.
“These treatments allow adolescents to thrive and to flourish,” he said. “And withholding them casts them back into serious distress.”
Jeffrey Harris, an attorney for the state, said the evidence doesn’t show that the treatment has “profound benefits.”
veryGood! (719)
Related
- Senate begins final push to expand Social Security benefits for millions of people
- New Jersey lawmakers advance $56.6 billion budget, hiking taxes on businesses aiming to help transit
- George Latimer wins NY-16 primary, CBS News projects, beating incumbent Jamaal Bowman
- Trail Blazers select Donovan Clingan with seventh pick of 2024 NBA draft. What to know
- Juan Soto to be introduced by Mets at Citi Field after striking record $765 million, 15
- Michael Jackson's Son Prince Shares Heartbreaking Message on 15th Anniversary of His Death
- All-star country lineup including Dolly Parton and Chris Stapleton honors Tom Petty in new album
- Jeopardy! Has Fans Buzzing Over Zendaya Question
- The 401(k) millionaires club keeps growing. We'll tell you how to join.
- Target Circle Week: 'Biggest sale of the season' includes 50% off toys. Here's how to shop in July
Ranking
- Meet first time Grammy nominee Charley Crockett
- Local leaders say election districts dilute Black votes for panel governing Louisiana’s capital
- 'Forever 7': Grieving family of murdered Oklahoma girl eager for execution 40 years later
- Texas inmate Ramiro Gonzales set for execution on teen victim's birthday: Here's what to know
- In ‘Nickel Boys,’ striving for a new way to see
- Skye Blakely injures herself on floor during training at U.S. Olympic gymnastics trials
- Funeral service set for 12-year-old Houston girl whose body was found in a creek
- Michael Phelps slams Olympic anti-doping efforts during testimony
Recommendation
Rylee Arnold Shares a Long
NYC’s transit budget is short $16 billion. Here are the proposed cuts, as the governor seeks funds
Funeral service set for 12-year-old Houston girl whose body was found in a creek
Delta Air Lines opens spacious new lounge at JFK airport. See what's inside.
Military service academies see drop in reported sexual assaults after alarming surge
IRS delays in resolving identity theft cases are ‘unconscionable,’ an independent watchdog says
What Is It Really Like Partying With Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce? Jimmy Kimmel Explains
Why Lindsay Lohan's Advice to New Moms Will Be Their Biggest Challenge