Current:Home > StocksTrump embraces the Jan. 6 rioters on the trail. In court, his lawyers hope to distance him from them -GrowthInsight
Trump embraces the Jan. 6 rioters on the trail. In court, his lawyers hope to distance him from them
SignalHub View
Date:2025-04-11 10:55:04
WASHINGTON (AP) — Donald Trump has embraced the rioters who attacked the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021 as patriots, vowed to pardon a large portion of them if he wins a second term and even collaborated on a song with a group of jailed defendants.
In his election interference case in Washington, his lawyers are taking a different tack.
Despite losing a bid to strike from the indictment references to that day’s violence, defense attorneys have made clear their strategy involves distancing the former president from the horde of rioters, whom they describe as “independent actors at the Capitol.” At the same time, special counsel Jack Smith’s team has signaled it will make the case that Trump is responsible for the chaos that unfolded, and point to Trump’s continued support of the Jan. 6 defendants to help establish his criminal intent.
The competing arguments highlight the extent to which the riot serves as an inescapable backdrop in a landmark trial set to begin on March 4 in a courthouse just blocks away from the Capitol.
It also reflects a point of separation between Trump and his legal team in the case accusing the front-runner for the Republican presidential nomination of conspiring to overturn his 2020 election loss. While Trump’s glorification of Jan. 6 defendants may boost him politically as he vies to retake the White House in 2024, his lawyers’ approach lays bare a concern that arguments linking him to the rioters could harm him in front of a jury.
Though Trump is not charged with inciting the riot, any success he hopes to have at trial may turn in part on his defense team’s ability to neutralize, or at least minimize, the ghoulish images of the violence that prosecutors cite as a natural extension of the former president’s repeated lies about a stolen election.
Much may depend as well on the evidence permitted by U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan. Trump’s lawyers have signaled they will try to block prosecutors from presenting at trial evidence related to the actions of the rioters, who shattered windows, beat police officers, and sent lawmakers running into hiding.
“What’s likely to happen here is for the judge to strike some type of reasonable balance, which will allow prosecutors to admit some portion of the evidence about the conduct and some of the violence that went on during that day, but will put some kinds of limits on just how far prosecutors can go in presenting evidence of violent conduct,” said Robert Mintz, a defense attorney and former federal prosecutor in New Jersey who has followed the case.
Trump has denied any wrongdoing in the case, which he has characterized as politically motivated.
In separate civil cases seeking to hold Trump liable for the Capitol attack, his lawyers have argued he encouraged his supporters to peacefully protest the results of the election and never called for any violence. The federal appeals court in Washington is currently weighing whether Trump can be sued by lawmakers and police officers, who have accused him of inciting the riot.
Trump will stand trial in the same courthouse where roughly 1,200 of his supporters have been charged in the largest investigation in Justice Department history. More than 800 of them have pleaded guilty or been convicted at trial of federal crimes stemming from the riot, including seditious conspiracy and assaulting police officers. About two-thirds of those sentenced so far have received prison time.
The former president often speaks on the campaign trail about what he says is the mistreatment of those defendants, many of whom have argued in court that they were following his instructions to go to Washington and to the Capitol on Jan. 6. Judges and juries, however, have rejected the argument that rioters who said they were acting at Trump’s direction can’t be held responsible for their crimes.
At a recent rally in Houston, Trump took the stage to a song titled “Justice For All,” featuring a choir of jailed Jan. 6 participants and Trump reciting the Pledge of Allegiance. He told the crowd: “I call them the J6 hostages, not prisoners.”
In court, however, his lawyers argued that references to the rioters’ conduct are irrelevant and that details of that day’s violence would only prejudice the jury against their client because they “may wrongfully impute fault to President Trump for these actions.” They are also seeking to force prosecutors to hand over the defense statements by prosecutors in Jan. 6 rioters’ cases they say undercuts Smith’s argument that Trump is responsible for the violence.
Judge Chutkan recently rejected Trump’s bid to strike references to the riot from the indictment, saying he “has not satisfied his burden to clearly show that they are prejudicial.”
Smith’s team has previewed how prosecutors will make the case that Trump used the angry mob as “a tool” in his campaign to pressure then- Vice President Mike Pence and obstruct the certification of Biden’s victory in a bid to desperate bid to subvert the will of voters.
Prosecutors have suggested they will show jurors the video of Trump’s speech before the riot in which he urged the crowd to go to the Capitol and “fight like hell.” They have also indicated they may seek to call rioters as witnesses, saying they will provide testimony that people who were at the Ellipse when Trump told them to “fight” went on to violently attack the Capitol. And they plan to highlight Trump’s continued embrace of the rioters to make the case that he intended for the chaos at the Capitol that day.
“There is a robust public record of how rioters’ actions at the Capitol on January 6 were extraordinarily violent and destructive, including attacks on law enforcement officers with flag poles, tasers, bear spray, and stolen riot shields and batons,” Smith’s team wrote in a recent court filing. “Despite this, the defendant has never wavered in his support of January 6 offenders.”
Though it’s easy to see why the defense team would push to limit such references, it’s also clear why prosecutors would see his encouragement and supportive words for the rioters as incriminating evidence that speaks to a criminal intent about his desire to overturn an election he had lost, said Tim Belevetz, a Washington attorney and former Justice Department prosecutor.
“The charges in the indictment require proof that President Trump acted knowingly and corruptly to overturn the election results,” he said, adding that from the Smith’s team perspective, “the actions at the Capitol that day are relevant to his state of mind, his intent and motive,” he said.
___
Richer reported from Boston. Associated Press writer Michelle Price in New York and Michael Kunzelman in Washington contributed to this report.
veryGood! (9734)
Related
- US appeals court rejects Nasdaq’s diversity rules for company boards
- Ukraine pilots to arrive in U.S. for F-16 fighter jet training next month
- Shooting that followed fight on street in Pasadena, California, wounds 5
- Should I get a COVID shot? CDC warns most should wait for September
- Rolling Loud 2024: Lineup, how to stream the world's largest hip hop music festival
- Appellate judges revive Jewish couple’s lawsuit alleging adoption bias under Tennessee law
- Texas trial over Biden policy letting migrants from 4 countries into US to wrap up Friday
- Alabama teen charged with capital murder after newborn infant found in trash bin
- Tarte Shape Tape Concealer Sells Once Every 4 Seconds: Get 50% Off Before It's Gone
- List of NFL players suspended for violating gambling policies
Ranking
- The Louvre will be renovated and the 'Mona Lisa' will have her own room
- No sign plane crash that likely killed Yevgeny Prigozhin was caused by surface-to-air missile, Pentagon says
- Virginia lawmakers say they have deal on ‘major components’ of budget, including rebates, tax cuts
- Activists furious Democratic leaders haven’t denounced plan to check every ‘Stop Cop City’ signature
- Tarte Shape Tape Concealer Sells Once Every 4 Seconds: Get 50% Off Before It's Gone
- ECB’s Lagarde says interest rates to stay high as long as needed to defeat inflation
- Scammers impersonate bank employees to steal nearly $2M from Pennsylvania customers, officials say
- Hawaii’s cherished notion of family, the ‘ohana, endures in tragedy’s aftermath
Recommendation
Trump's 'stop
These Are the 10 Avec Les Filles Fall Jackets That Belong in Every Closet
Missouri judge says ban on gender-affirming health care for minors can take effect on Monday
3 men exonerated in NYC after case reviews spotlighted false confessions in 1990s
Tom Holland's New Venture Revealed
New Mexico governor demands changes to make horse racing drug-free
Players credit the NFL and union with doing a better job of teaching when sports betting isn’t OK
Boston announces new plan to rid city of homeless encampment, get residents help